| Platinum | Pale Horse Coffee |
| Gold | Sun Flour Cafe (formerly TranquiliTea) |
| Silver | 17 Hands Coffee |
| Bronze | Amazing Glazed |
| Top Pick | Battle Grounds Coffeehouse |
| Top Pick | Bergey's Breadbasket Bakery & More |
| Top Pick | Court House Cafe |
| Top Pick | Gather |
| Top Pick | Irwin's Fountain |
| Top Pick | The Cutting Edge Cafe |
| Huddle House |