| Platinum | Taqueria La Hacienda |
| Gold | Burrito Perdido |
| Silver | 3 Amigos Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Rancho Grande Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Loro Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Puente Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | El Toro Loco |
| Top Pick | Los Primos Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Moe's Southwest Grill |
| Top Pick | Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant |