| Platinum | Chesapeake Pizza |
| Gold | Frank's Pizza |
| Silver | Sal's NY Pizza |
| Bronze | Pizzeria Bella Vista |
| Top Pick | Andiamo Ristorante & Pizza Napoletana |
| Top Pick | Baba's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Great Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tossed & Sauced |
| Top Pick | Vino Italian Bistro |