| Platinum | Pirate's Cove Restaurant |
| Gold | Wicker's Crab Pot Seafood |
| Silver | Margie & Rays |
| Bronze | Redbones Raw Bar & Seafood Grill |
| Top Pick | Amber Lantern Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Black Pelican in Chesapeake |
| Top Pick | Skrimp Shack |
| Top Pick | Surf Rider Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Butcher's Son |