| Platinum | McGrath's Burger Shack |
| Gold | Five Guys |
| Silver | Metro Diner |
| Bronze | Burger Haven |
| Top Pick | Angie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Freddy's |
| Top Pick | Hotrodders Cafe |
| Top Pick | Perfectly Frank |
| Top Pick | Simply George Burger Joint & Beer VB |
| Top Pick | Winston's Cafe |